NYC school research

Best Private Elementary Schools in NYC? Compare Fit & Cost

Editorial review: · Dataset years are labeled separately below.

The best private elementary school is a fit decision, not a defensible citywide test-score ranking. Start with grade span and travel, then verify teaching approach, learning support and the full annual cost with each school. Our directory data supports a shortlist, not a claim that one private school is academically best.

Browse private schools serving elementary grades

What to compare before deciding

Decision criteria and their limitations
DecisionCompareAsk the school
Daily fitBorough, address and entry gradeCan we visit during a normal school day?
ContinuityElementary-only versus a longer grade spanDoes continuing to the next division require another application?
Classroom experienceReported enrollment and stated programsWhat are actual class sizes and learning-support arrangements?
AffordabilityCurrent tuition plus required extrasWhat are the dated fee schedule and aid deadlines?

What our school records show

373 of 623 distinct private-school records explicitly include elementary grades (K–5). This is database coverage, not a count of open seats or a ranked list.

304 of these elementary-serving records also list grades through at least eighth grade. A longer grade span may reduce school changes, but does not guarantee progression between divisions.

373 of these 373 records have a source year: 2024 (81 schools); 2022 (292 schools). Different survey years should not be treated as one current-year snapshot.

Recorded coverage—not admissions availability
Manhattan105
Brooklyn106
Queens113
Bronx33
Staten Island16
Not recorded0

Find your options

373 matching school records · showing 1–25

Swipe the table horizontally to see every measure and data year.

School records and data coverage
SchoolBoroughRecorded grade spanWhole-school enrollmentNCES source yearRecorded affiliation / typeStudents per FTE teacherCurrent tuition / aid
A FANTIS PAROCHIAL SCHOOLBB061076Record sourceBrooklynK-111232022Affiliation not recorded / day7.1Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
A PLUS KIDZ ACADEMYA1902950Record sourceBrooklynK-442022Affiliation not recorded / day4Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
ABC PRESCHOOL & KINDERGARTEN CENTERBB964100Record sourceQueensK-182022Affiliation not recorded / day8Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
ACADEMY OF ST DOROTHY00920174Record sourceStaten IslandK-111772022Affiliation not recorded / day18.6Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
ACADEMY OF ST JOSEPH00921917Record sourceManhattanPK-10962024Catholic / day7.83Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
AHI EZER YESHIVA SCHOOL00936162Record sourceBrooklynK-111252022Affiliation not recorded / day8.7Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
AL-IMAN SCHOOLA9104867Record sourceQueensK-10362022Affiliation not recorded / day5.9Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
ALEXANDER ROBERTSON SCHOOL00938272Record sourceManhattanK-7612024Non-Religious / day3.37Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
ALLEN CHRISTIAN SCHOOLA9303704Record sourceQueensK-4162022Affiliation not recorded / day5.3Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
ARISTA PREPARATORY ACADEMYBB161723Record sourceBrooklyn1-5222022Affiliation not recorded / day7.3Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
ASTORIA LUTHERAN SCHOOL00941161Record sourceQueensK-11662022Affiliation not recorded / day5.8Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BAIS RUCHEL DSATMAR GIRLS SCHOOLA1502437Record sourceBrooklyn1-111,3702022Affiliation not recorded / day16.4Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BAIS YAAKOV BNOS ALIYAA2000003Record sourceManhattan4-11302022Affiliation not recorded / day4.8Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BAIS YAAKOV OF 18TH AVEAA000069Record sourceBrooklynK-112692022Affiliation not recorded / day13.6Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BANK STREET SCHOOL FOR CHILDREN00939298Record sourceManhattanPK-104132024Non-Religious / day5.76Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BARKAI FOUNDATION INC.A0302194Record sourceBrooklynK-113152022Affiliation not recorded / day5.4Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BASIS INDEPENDENT MANHATTANA1790364Record sourceManhattanK-81342022Affiliation not recorded / day4.5Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BATTALION CHRISTIAN ACADEMYA9303708Record sourceBrooklyn1-8572022Affiliation not recorded / day9.5Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BATTERY PARK MONTESSORIA1990549Record sourceManhattanPK-K682024Non-Religious / day0.27Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BAY RIDGE CATHOLIC ACADEMY00924703Record sourceBrooklynK-113212022Affiliation not recorded / day14.9Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BAY RIDGE CHRISTIAN ACADEMYA9104699Record sourceBrooklyn1-11812022Affiliation not recorded / day7.2Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BEIT RABBAN DAY SCHOOLA9303881Record sourceManhattanPK-101422024Other Religious / day4.95Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BET YAAKOV ATERET TORAHA9903137Record sourceBrooklynK-116762022Affiliation not recorded / day6Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BET YAAKOV ATERET TORAH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLA2102525Record sourceBrooklynK-116762022Affiliation not recorded / day6.5Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule
BETH JACOB PAROCHIAL SCHOOL00936355Record sourceManhattanPK-101522024Other Religious / day9.12Not independently verified — request a dated fee and aid schedule

All matching canonical NCES IDs, alphabetically, not endorsements. Grade spans and affiliations are recorded import values, not independently confirmed current provision. Ungraded/unknown ranges are excluded. Source year dates the directory survey, not tuition. Whole-school students per full-time-equivalent teacher is not class size. We withhold unverified tuition amounts and do not treat missing aid/affiliation fields as “no.” Use each NCES source and school website to check identity, grades and current admissions.

What a real cost comparison changes

Two source-checked examples illustrate why sticker prices need grade and fee context. These are not the cheapest schools, a ranked recommendation or a complete market survey.

Official 2026–27 fees · sources checked October 25, 2026
SchoolElementary tuitionWhat changes the comparisonOfficial admissions / aid source
Bank Street School for ChildrenK–4: $68,885; grade 5: $71,545Books, trips and materials included. Lunch, early care, lower-school after-school and the $100 parent-association fee are additional.Dated tuition and financial aid · How to apply
Dalton SchoolK–12: $70,800Includes lunch, books, classroom supplies, devices and listed class trips. The $100 family parent-association dues are additional.Dated tuition, inclusions and aid application

For K–4, the published tuition difference is $1,915 before extras and aid; for grade 5, Bank Street’s listed tuition is $745 higher. Different inclusions mean neither difference is a reliable net-cost comparison. Ask for a personalized aid estimate and a full annual budget.

Data-quality finding: Bank Street’s stored PK–10 range conflicts with its official page listing provision through eighth grade. Dalton has two NCES records at different addresses with matching enrollment totals. We flag these rather than merging IDs, adding those enrollments together, or treating directory records as distinct institutions. Profiles retain their existing URLs while source reconciliation is reviewed.

What the data can—and cannot—compare

NCES directory records are useful for school identity, grades and enrollment. They are not a common academic assessment of private schools. We do not apply public-school test ratings to these records or interpret a missing tuition field as free tuition.

Compare like with like

Whole-school enrollment at a K–12 school is not its elementary enrollment. A student–teacher ratio is not class size. Use the grade span next to every enrollment number, and request division-specific figures before drawing conclusions.

Build a shortlist with evidence

Choose two or three feasible commutes. Ask each school the same questions about literacy instruction, differentiation, support staffing, after-school arrangements and total cost. Keep dated answers so that your comparison reflects the same admission year.

Before you pay an application fee

Confirm your child’s exact entry grade, the application year, required visits or assessments, application and aid deadlines, and whether aid is available in that division. Ask what is included in tuition, which extras are mandatory and how costs change when moving to the next division. The dated tuition examples below show why headline prices need grade and fee context; they are not a current quote for your family.

Sources and data limits

Editorial review is not a new data release. Linked profiles identify available measures and years. Verify current admissions, program operation and seats with official sources.

Your next step

Browse private schools serving elementary grades